Stress Testing the Canadian Market Neutral Fund for Rising Interest Rates

Download article in PDF format.  

 

Hillsdale's return forecasts, risk control and portfolio construction methodologies were simulated in a proprietary test environment from January 1994 to December 2003. Monthly returns net of disturbance costs and fees were regressed against coincident changes in Government of Canada 3 month Tbill rates. As seen below, the strategy generates average monthly net returns of 1.11% with a small positive bias to rising interest rates.

Market Neutral Returns vs. 3 Month T-Bills

Returns were then separated into periods of either falling or rising rates. Monthly returns during periods of rising rates were re-combined ('bootstrapped') into a single return stream. During months where T-bill rates increased (53 observations), the strategy generated average monthly net returns of 1.57% with approximately 83% of the months being positive.

Periods of rising interest rates were then further clustered into "normal" periods, defined as a monthly increase of between 20-50 bps (15 observations) and "stress" periods, defined as a monthly increase of greater then 50 bps (7 observations).

During periods of "normal" interest hikes the strategy generated an average monthly positive net return of 1.26% with approximately 87% of the months being positive. During periods of "stress", the strategy generated an average monthly return of 0.74% with approximately 86% of the months being positive. Individual months and returns are shown in Tables 1 and 2.

All Hillsdale strategies are designed over 20-30 years of rigorous in and out of sample testing. Specific attention is paid to avoid the use of 'fat tail' forecast variables which often arise from the mining of a single regime environment or from the use of purely linear techniques. The Canadian Market Neutral Equity fund is constructed to be neutral to most known macro factors including yield curve shifts and changes in credit spreads and inflation. While we recognize that a given macro environment is only a small contributor to the returns of this strategy, it is important to underline that a rising interest rate environment has rarely negatively impacted these returns and that through all aggregate periods of rising rates, the Canadian Market Neutral strategy provided returns significantly in excess of cash.

Further information on Hillsdale's Investment Methodology can be found here.

Similar information on the Hillsdale Canadian long/short Aggressive Hedged Fund and Hillsdale Canadian Performance Fund can be found by contacting John Motherwell directly at (416) 913-3923.


Table 1: Normal Months
Date TB > 20 bps
< 50 bps
CMN
Return
Feb 94 22 2.56%
April 94 35 -0.74%
May 94 36 0.98%
Nov 94 48 1.28%
March 97 31 2.79%
June 97 26 2.70%
Dec 97 25 0.52%
Jan 98 50 -2.89%
April 98 31 1.24%
July 98 24 2.81%
Feb 99 25 2.19%
March 00 29 5.50%
May 00 20 0.08%
Jan 03 22 1.77%
March 03 23 0.47%
Average Return: 1.26%
Frequency: 13/15


Table 2: Stress Months
Date TB > 50 bps CMN
Return
March 94 178 0.45%
Dec 94 88 1.77%
Jan 95 122 1.86%
March 95 59 0.90%
Oct 97 59 1.74%
Aug 98 65 0.05%
Dec 99 52 -1.60%
Average Return: 0.74%
Frequency: 6/7


© Copyright 2004, Hillsdale Investment Management